The Existence of White Holes May Settle One of Physics’ Biggest Debates

Longtime viewers of this channel know that we talk about black holes a lot.

We just can’t seem to get enough of them.

We give them so much attention but today we’re going to talk about their bizarro twins, white


Basically, a white hole is the hypothetical opposite of a black hole.

Now I’d bet that you know what a black hole is, but hey, they still have to explain seat

belts every time you fly on an airplane, so buckle up because after the refresher we’re

going on a wild ride.

Black holes are regions of space where so much mass is packed together so densely it

forms what’s called a singularity, and nothing can move fast enough to escape its gravitational


Not even the fastest thing in the universe, light, can escape its clutches.

But you knew that right?

Everybody knows what a black hole is… except that nobody knows what a black hole is, not

exactly anyway.

Because of that pesky fact that light can’t escape, we can’t see what’s going on inside

a black hole.

So we have to rely on theories and equations to deduce what’s happening at the center

of the event horizon, and that has been a major sticking point in physics.

There are two competing explanations to describe black holes.

One of them is Einstein’s theory of general relativity, where the mass of a black hole

bends spacetime so much that it becomes one single point of infinite density.

On the other hand, according to quantum mechanics there can’t be an infinitely small point.

It can be very very small, but not infinitely so.

And this irreconcilable difference is one of the greatest debates in physics, since

general relativity is our best description of gravity, while quantum mechanics has been

called the most successful theory ever.

But some physicists believe white holes could  square these two predictions and reveal what’s

happening inside a black hole.

The equations of general relativity allow for the possibility of white holes, all you

have to do is set the mass of the singularity to zero and everything gets turned on its


Instead of a cosmic vacuum that sucks up everything that strays too close, you get a… whatever

the opposite of a vacuum is?

I’m not good with metaphors, but the point is all it can do is spew stuff out.

But then the question is, how do you get a singularity, a point of infinite density remember,

with no mass?

And how does a massless singularity spit anything out?

Because of that head scratcher white holes have long been written off as a mathematical

quirk but not something that can happen in reality.

However, quantum mechanics allows for some “adjustments” to the solutions of the

equations of general relativity, and with those adjustments, the interior of a black

hole could transform into a white hole.

One physicist describes it as though the curved spacetime of the black hole itself is bouncing

out again, and this rebound opens up some tantalizing possibilities.

Since a black hole might transform into a white hole, that means things falling into

it may come out again.

This would solve another issue quantum physics has with black holes because in quantum physics

information cannot be destroyed.

Granted, whatever came out of a white hole would be a very mangled version of its former

self, but nonetheless, information about what it was would not be deleted from the universe.

It sounds like a wormhole, but instead of traveling through space, the object would

travel through time.

General relativity tells us that time moves more slowly near massive objects, so to an

object falling into the black hole it would seem like very little time is passing, but

to an outside observer, it would take ages to pop out again on the rebound.

Just how far into the future it travels depends on the size of the black hole, with big holes

taking quadrillions of times the age of the universe to transition.

But small black holes that formed just after the chaos of the Big Bang may have already


They would be invisible because they’d be smaller than the wavelength of light, but

have the mass of about a millionth of a gram.

White hole proponents say this could make them an attractive candidate for dark matter.

Yeah, the upsides of white holes just keep getting better and better.

I told you it would be a wild ride but here is where it comes to an end.

I have to remind you that white holes are still purely hypothetical.

The math checks out and the reasons to hunt for them are numerous, but at this stage they

remain a very unexplored corner of physics.

Then again, there was a time when the same could be said about black holes.

We’re just going to need a few physicists dedicated enough to the idea of white holes

to keep searching for them.

That or a few brave volunteers to jump into a black hole. huh?

Who’s going with me, huh?


White holes may form faster when the black holes are less massive, but black holes themselves

can merge and get bigger.

There’s a debate whether the very biggest supermassive black holes can come together

and for more on that check out my video here.

Alright, so I mean it. Who's jumping in with me huh?!

Who's going in the nearest black hole?!

Let us know down in the comments below. Be sure to subscribe to Seeker,

and I will see you next time.